I’d agree that all build (even if it’s entertaining) and no payoff would suck - like if “Stairway to Heaven” had 20 more minutes of the mellow part before the climax - but I felt like Hyperion’s individual vignettes were rewarding unto themselves.

I think this particular comparison to LOTR is valid. *SPOILER ALERT* Hyperion’s “off-to-see-the-wizard” ending is just as incomplete as Sam and Frodo floating away at the end of “Fellowship”. In both cases, I rushed to read the next book. If I’d disliked either, then I’d probably have stopped there (like Summer did).

One thing that I got from the show is that Summer was a little (maybe more than a little) annoyed that the book was violating a lot of “rules” about story telling. That’s one of those things, like a bad itch, that can be really distracting. Glaring errors, or pet-peeves can really prevent someone from liking a book, or movie for that matter.

For instance, my wife *hates* LotRs solely because of the writing style. She can’t get past it. “Who wants to read two pages of history about a rock?” she says. Hyperion is like that, but I enjoy it’s immersive aspect. Perhaps Simmons could have trimmed the book down, but I think that would have harmed the book.

From one point of view, nothing happens. I don’t agree with that. As you read the stories, you get a sense of a bigger picture. Hyperion provides a mosaic of a battle that is about to begin.

Yes, the book is “like looking at a very detailed painting REAL close up and trying to find the story among the pretty colors.” It is like the famous Seurat painting “Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte” — it’s the pointilistic painting featured in Ferris Bueller’s Day Off. If you spend too much time focusing on the dots, you’ll miss the big picture.

Hyperion is definitely not an action book. Though it is a bit of work to read, I think it is worth it.

How in the world can Hyperion be compared to LOTR? Yes LOTR was a long book chopped up into three books, BUT you caould also get a sense of where it was going. Same with the Hobbit. There was conflict, there was character change, there was everything a story should have.

As Joe pointed out, there was NONE of that in Hyperion. It took pages and pages just to get a person to stand up and walk off the dang ship. Get on with it. It’s nice to stop and smell the roses for a while and the prose is excellent, but the story gets lost in the shrubbery with this one.

For me this was a book that took months to finish because it was SO slowly paced, there’s no ‘real’ action, and each scene is dragged out for pages after pages with only a smattering of dialogue. It was like looking at a very detailed painting REAL close up and trying to find the story among the pretty colors.

That’s my take anyway and I can understand how some can like something like this. Though it failed to really grab me past book one. I didn’t care enough when I was done to fight with another. I’d rather read something where ’stuff’ happens.

And I’ve since bought the first three books again, the new trade pb editions, and passed on the mmpbs to a friend who I know would enjoy them.

Hmm… I’m having a thought here.

I’m also a huge fan of the Uplift books by David Brin, The Gap series by Stephen R. Donaldson (and the Thomas Covenant books, but it’s been YEARS since I’ve read those), and the Sunrunner books by Melanie Rawn. There’s lots more, but I’ll stop there.

I think I read Downbelow Station, but not the following stories… and I can’t recall much of it, alas.

FYI, the Faded Sun trilogy was recently reprinted in an omnibus edition… all three books collected as one. So it wouldn’t cost as much to reacquire

As for Cherryh, I was mostly thinking of the Company Wars (Downbelow Station, etc) and Cyteen books, possibly with the Chanur books. I never read Foreigner, et. al. and it’s been a long time since I read the Faded Sun trilogy, although I do remember liking them a lot. I’d re-read them but, see, there was this ‘family’ incident a few years ago that cost me a lot of my books, and I haven’t wanted to spend the money to replace everything I lost.

Kinda fits the whole “past is present” meme, doesn’t it?

I enjoyed the first Deryni trilogy, thought that the King Kelson trilogy was okay, but the next batch didn’t hold my interest, so I stopped reading any of the subsequent Deryni tales.

About the Cherryh books, are you talking about the ones that begin with Foreigner and Invader? I haven’t read those, but a long time ago I read her Faded Sun trilogy… might be time for a reread of those (when I have time!)

There’s also Saberhagen’s Empire of the East, and Poul Anderson’s The Broken Sword, too.

I keep meaning to send you an email with ideas for future shows but I’m lazy so here are a couple:

Julian May’s Pliocene Exile and Milieu books

Anything by Robert Heinlein, but Moon is a Harsh Mistress might be topical (movie rumors popping up again)

Katherine Kurtz’ Deryni ‘verse

CJ Cherryh’s future histories

(in case you didn’t notice the pattern, I really like fictional ‘verses with lots of stories set in them)